Thursday, February 25, 2010

Day 2 - 2007 Round 2

1RIC AnchormenTim Lincecum (P SF)
2North Kingstown FriarsYovani Gallardo (P MIL)
3Poland PandasJustin Upton (OF ARI)
4Blind DogsChris B. Young (OF ARI)
5Bad Ass BombersBilly Butler (OF KC)
6Rhode Island QuahogsAndrew McCutchen (OF PIT)
7The NamesTroy Tulowitzki (SS COL)
8Modesto NutsReid Brignac (SS TB)
9Rhody RampageAdam Miller (P CLE)
10Attack Pigeons of ConnecticutAndy LaRoche (3B LA)
11The CarbombsMatt Garza (P MIN)
12The Brew CrewRyan J. Braun (3B MIL)


By Brendan Hart

Best Pick- Tim Lincecum- The Anchormen drafted “The Freak” as the 1st pick in the 2nd rd and then later traded him away in a forgettable deal. While there were many great players selected in this round (Braun, Tulo, Upton, Gallardo), it’s hard to argue against a 26 yr old two time CY Young winner. Lincecum has easily earned his title as the best pitcher in baseball with back to back seasons of over 260 strikeouts and an era not exceeding 2.62. Barring an injury from his violent mechanics he should be able to continue dominating on the Rampage’s staff for years to come. If the draft were to be done over today he would have been in the top 3 picks.

Worst Pick- Adam Miller-It’s safe to say that the Indians and Rampage never imagined that Adam Miller would still be in the minor leagues heading into the 2010 season. Miller, a first round pick of the Indians in 2003, has an injury history that rivals Mark Prior. As of December 2009 he had undergone four surgeries including “reconstructive surgery on the middle finger of his throwing hand”. All these injuries derailed a promising career and ruined his potential of being the Indians/Rampage’s ace. It’s hard to blame Rampage owner Jeff Lester with the pick considering Baseball America ranked Miller as the Indians top prospect from 2005-2008 (Made the Top 100 list all five years including three times in the top 29 picks). Needless to say at this point he can safely be considered a bust and will probably be out of baseball within the next two years.

Still Could Make It- Reid Brignac- Ranked number 17 on the 2007 BA Top 100 list, Brignac seemed to have the potential to turn into the 20+ homerun shortstop that everyone craves in fantasy. Ben Moss errr people actually at the draft, took Brignac thinking he may build on his breakout 2006 season in Class A where he hit over 320 with 21 homeruns and 12 steals. Unfortunately since Moss has been missing from the NKFBL so has Brignacs power. In the past three seasons he’s only seen 35 balls exit the stadium and has never been able to hit close to the average he showed in 2006. Still Brignac is only 24 years old and did show improvement in AAA where he cut down his K’s from 93 to 69 and raised his obp to respectable level. With more AB’s he could settle into the Majors as a 12-15 hr shortstop in the future.

% in MLB- 11 out of 12, 92% Every player from the 2nd round of the 2007 Prospect Draft except Adam Miller has made the show.

3 comments:

  1. who was the other Miller from that year? Andrew? Isn't he on Florida? What happened to him?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Obviously there's a great argument either way but I would personally have a hard time not giving the best pick to Ryan Braun in this round. I drafted him with the last pick in the round, so 11 picks after Lincecum and Braun is all but guaranteed to get drafted ahead of Lincecum in any yearly draft these days.

    Granted, in real life baseball Lincecum has had a more prestigious career so far winning two Cy Youngs but in fantasy and especially an offensive minded league like ours, im guessing the majority of people would take Braun.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with most of what you said. I probably should have given the edge to Braun because of where you drafted him.

    The numbers clearly favor Lince for the last two years.

    Braun
    08 544 Points (Ranked 31st)
    09 621 Points (Ranked 7th, ESPN Player Rater 7)

    Lince
    08 654 Points (Ranked 8th)
    09 657 Points (Ranked 6th, ESPN Player Rater 4)

    ReplyDelete